We are providing a link to the third party's website solely as a convenience to you, because we believe that website may provide useful content. We do not control the content on the third-party website; we do not guarantee any claims made on it; nor do we endorse the website, its sponsor, or any of the content, policies, activities, products or services offered on the website or by any advertiser on the site. We disclaim any responsibility for the website’s performance or interaction with your computer, its security and privacy policies and practices, and any consequences that may result from visiting it. The link is not intended to create an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy or hold, any securities.
Click the link above to continue or CANCEL
Commentaries & market updates.
John Snow’s Hobson’s choice
John Snow’s Hobson’s choice
In an interview this morning on CNBC, following the release of yet another
monthly trade deficit in excess of 40 billion dollars, Treasury Secretary John
Snow was presented with a Hobson’s choice when asked if he was worried about
the current account deficit. Posed in such terms, the question is ridiculous
on its face. The query is akin to asking a CEO if he is worried about his company’s
massive, continuous and indefinite quarterly losses. However, the stupidly
of the question was only exceeded by the stupidity of the answer.
In classic Orwelian style, Mr. Snow replied that he was not worried at all
and declared that the current account deficit was a reflection of the attractiveness
of U.S. assets, and blamed America’s faltering exports on overseas weakness.
To use the same analogy, this is like a CEO of a money losing company stating
that its enormous debt is merely a reflection of the attractiveness of its
bonds, and that its faltering revenues are not a matter of concern because
they simply reflect the problems of its customers.
Downplaying so obvious a problem sends a terrible message to the currency
markets and to America’s creditors. After all, if the Treasury Secretary is
not worried about the growing and enormous current account deficit, nothing
will be done to prevent it from getting even worse. Therefore, the correct
response to such compliancy would be to sell the dollar. However, upon deeper
reflection, it was the only answer that a treasury secretary pursuing a mythical “strong
dollar policy” could give. A truthful reply would have been an official
admission that the current account deficit is in fact a problem, the reaction
to which would have been even more dollar negative.
The next time that a reporter asks Mr. Snow this question, this best thing
that he can do would be to change the subject. Or better yet, refrain from
giving interviews at all, and simply issue occasional press releases declaring
that “a strong dollar is in the national interest” and hope for the
Sign up for our Free Reports & Market Updates.